Italy fines Meta $887 million over Facebook's Android photo access
Italy fines Meta €805 million ($887 million) over a Facebook Android feature that read users' photo galleries without specific consent. What it means for you.

What happened
Italy fines Meta €805 million, about $887 million, after its data protection authority found that the Facebook app for Android read photos, videos and their metadata from users' phone galleries without specific consent. The regulator gave Meta 60 days to switch the gallery-suggestions feature off by default and ask for permission separately. Meta says it will appeal.
Key takeaways
- It is the largest fine Italy's privacy regulator has ever issued, equal to about 0.47% of Meta's worldwide revenue.
- About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, according to the regulator.
- The case did not examine whether the photos were used to train AI. Meta denies that, and the regulator plans a separate look at a newer cloud-processing feature.
In this article
Italy's privacy watchdog just handed Meta the biggest bill in its history, and the reason is a feature most Facebook users have probably never thought about. On Saturday, Nov. 14, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million, or about $887 million, over the way the Facebook app for Android reached into people's photo galleries.
The regulator says the app read photos, videos and the metadata attached to them on Italian users' phones without asking for specific consent and without telling them clearly what it was doing. Meta disputes all of it and says it will appeal, according to the BBC.
Why Italy fined Meta
The case centers on a Facebook setting called "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook." It has been in the Android app since 2023. While you scroll, it pulls photos and videos from your phone's camera roll and offers them up as ideas for a new post.
Read also: Google's Pixel Tag goes on sale for $29.99, taking on Apple's AirTag · Samsung is discontinuing its News app on Galaxy phones and tablets · A researcher claims Samsung TVs run extensive ad tracking and audio telemetry
The Garante's problem wasn't the idea of suggestions. It was how Facebook got access in the first place. Its technical review found three things:
- Facebook asked for gallery access through one permission that covered the whole app, used by several features with different needs.
- The prompt before that permission carried a vague notice about enabling "other features," which didn't tell people they were also switching on gallery suggestions.
- The suggestions feature was already turned on by default.
Once someone grants full gallery access, the regulator wrote, the app can read the entire photo archive on the device, usually permanently, and neither the user nor the authority can check which images are actually being used.
The legal hook is Article 122 of Italy's privacy code, the country's version of the EU ePrivacy directive. That rule treats a smartphone as part of a person's private sphere. Reading anything stored on it needs free and informed consent, the Garante said, whether or not the data leaves the phone and whether or not anyone is harmed.
How the investigation started
It began in July 2025 with a complaint from a consumer protection group in Bolzano, in northern Italy. The Garante then ran its own technical analysis of the app.
Meta tried to argue the case belonged to Ireland's Data Protection Commission, since Meta's EU operations are based in Dublin. The Garante rejected that. Under the EU's GDPR, big tech cases usually go to a single lead regulator, but the ePrivacy rules don't have that "one-stop shop," so Italy kept the case.
How the $887 million fine was calculated
The Garante said it weighed several factors in setting the Meta fine:
- The number of people affected, about 20 million Android users in Italy.
- How long the violation has lasted. It is still going on for anyone who hasn't updated the app and for anyone who already granted the permission.
- A previous 2019 decision against the company.
- What it called Meta's poor cooperation during the investigation.
It gave Meta some credit for changes made after the complaint, though it called those changes late and said they only reach people who update the app. The final figure is about 0.47% of Meta's worldwide revenue. Al Jazeera reports it is by far the largest fine the Italian regulator has ever issued.
What Meta has to change, and when
The order comes with deadlines. Within 60 days, Meta must:
- Ask for consent to gallery suggestions in a separate, specific request that explains what the feature does, that it reads the gallery and how to turn it off.
- Keep the feature off by default, including for people who already gave the app photo access.
If Meta misses the deadline, it can't switch the feature on for anyone who hasn't given valid consent. The company also has to tell the Garante within 30 days what steps it has started and report the finished measures within 90 days.
What the case didn't cover: AI training
The decision doesn't address whether Meta used gallery photos to train artificial intelligence. Meta denies doing that, and the Garante didn't rule on it. The regulator did flag a newer Facebook feature, launched in 2026, that processes gallery content in the cloud, and said it may examine that one separately.
What Meta says
Meta pushed back hard. "We strongly disagree with the [regulator's] assessment of the facts, its application of the law, and the disproportionate level of the fine," the company told the BBC. It described gallery suggestions as a simple tool that helps people post, and said users must grant permission on their device before it works and can change that permission at any time.
A Meta spokesperson also confirmed the appeal plan to Reuters, via CNBC. An appeal would go through Italy's courts, so the fine and the order could be tied up for a while.
The Italian penalty lands a month after a bigger hit at home. In October, a judge in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after finding it had spent years misleading the public about how it handled Facebook user data, the BBC noted.
Does this affect Facebook users in the US?
Not directly. The Garante's order covers users in Italy and is based on Italian and EU law. Nobody in the US gets money from it, and Meta isn't required to change the feature for American accounts.
The US also has no federal privacy law like the EU's ePrivacy rule, which requires consent before an app reads what's stored on your phone. In the US, what Facebook can see on an Android phone mostly comes down to the permissions you grant it.
That's the practical takeaway for American readers. The regulator's complaint was that one tap gave Facebook access to everything in the gallery. You can narrow that yourself.
How to stop Facebook from accessing your photos on Android
On most Android phones the path looks like this, though the exact wording varies by phone maker:
- Open Settings and tap Apps.
- Find and tap Facebook, then Permissions.
- Tap Photos and videos.
- Choose Don't allow to block gallery access, or on Android 14 and newer, Allow limited access to pick only the photos Facebook can see.
Blocking it means you'll have to grant access again when you want to upload a picture. Limited access is the middle ground: Facebook sees the specific shots you select and nothing else. iPhone owners have a similar choice under Settings, Privacy & Security, Photos.
Questions about what our devices quietly collect keep coming up this fall. We looked at a security report on Samsung TVs and at Samsung shutting down its News app in recent weeks. For Meta, the clock is now running: two months to change how Facebook asks Italian users for their photos, unless a court agrees to pause the order.
Frequently asked questions
- Why did Italy fine Meta?
- Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, says Facebook's Android app accessed photos, videos and metadata in users' phone galleries for a "get suggestions from gallery" feature without specific, informed consent. The feature was on by default and relied on one broad app-wide permission.
- How much did Italy fine Meta?
- The fine is €805 million, which works out to about $887 million. The Garante says it equals roughly 0.47% of Meta's global annual revenue, and Al Jazeera reports it is by far the largest penalty the Italian regulator has ever imposed.
- Does the Meta Italy fine affect US users?
- Not directly. The ruling applies to Facebook users in Italy and rests on Italian and EU privacy law. US users won't see a refund or automatic change, but they can still limit what the Facebook app reads by changing its photo permission in Android settings.
- How do I stop Facebook from accessing my photos on Android?
- On most Android phones, open Settings, tap Apps, choose Facebook, then Permissions, then Photos and videos. Pick Don't allow, or on Android 14 and newer, Allow limited access to share only the pictures you choose. Menu names vary slightly by phone maker.
Sources
- Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro · Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, Nov. 14, 2026
- Italy fines Meta €805m over accessing users' photos · BBC News, Nov. 14, 2026
- Italy fines Meta $887 million over Android users' data access · CNBC / Reuters, Nov. 14, 2026
- Meta fined $887 million in Italy over Android gallery photos and videos on Facebook · Associated Press, Nov. 14, 2026
- Italy fines Meta $880m over photo privacy · Al Jazeera, Nov. 14, 2026
About the author
Founder and editor
Marcia Reid is the founder and editor of TrendCanopy, where she reviews and edits every story.
Spotted an error? Read our corrections policy or contact us. Last reviewed November 14, 2026.
Related stories
Google's Pixel Tag goes on sale for $29.99, taking on Apple's AirTag
The Google Pixel Tag goes on sale Nov. 11 for $29.99, or $99.99 for four. What the Android tracker does, which phones work and how it compares to AirTag.
Samsung is discontinuing its News app on Galaxy phones and tablets
The Samsung News app is being discontinued Dec. 21, 2026, per notices in India and South Korea. What ends, your data and how to switch to Google Discover.
A researcher claims Samsung TVs run extensive ad tracking and audio telemetry
Researcher log4j says a rooted 2025 Samsung TV runs extensive ad tracking and audio telemetry. What remains unproven, and how owners can opt out.
GTA 6 reviews give Rockstar a 99 on Metacritic, tying Zelda's all-time record
Critics gave Grand Theft Auto VI a 99 Metascore from more than 150 reviews hours before launch. What they praised, the few gripes, and when you can play it.
Apple outage knocks out the App Store and Apple Music as iCloud sign-ins fail
Apple's status page lists the App Store and Apple Music as down and iCloud sign-in as slow, while users also report Apple Pay trouble. Here's what we know.
Game Awards 2026 nominees put GTA 6 up for Game of the Year before it even launches
Geoff Keighley revealed The Game Awards 2026 nominees on Tuesday. GTA 6 leads with eight nods. See the Game of the Year field, voting and the Dec. 10 show.
Trending now
News ·
House Democrats pick Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, putting him in line to make historyNews ·
Florida flooding closes Broward schools after 15 inches of rain hits HollywoodEntertainment ·
Kevin Feige says Marvel was swapping Kang for Doom before Jonathan Majors was firedMoney ·
Anthropic prices its IPO at $83 a share, valuing the Claude maker at $1.5 trillionNews ·
Xi greets Trump on the tarmac in China, a welcome Putin didn't get




